Posted by Kristine Jacobson

cmg1Influencers have been getting a lot of bad press lately, and that’s understandable. As a new and explosively successful way to make money with nothing but a social media account and smartphone, the influencer lifestyle – like many other legitimate occupations before it – has been snatched up by unscrupulous personalities and embroiled in controversy that tarnishes its name.

Because they tread the line between maintaining an ostensibly real persona and running a marketing business, the arrival of influencers has been heralded by some as a prime example of the way social media can saturate and intrude on real life. In recent months, for instance, influencers have been caught faking mental breakdowns to advertise online therapy.

These are all reasons that the word “influencer” has come to carry a social stigma across the web. According to surveys, 47% of social media users were “fatigued” by influencer posts which they deemed “repetitive” in 2018. Accordingly, many have called for social networks to regulate influencer behavior to reduce dishonest or merely annoying behavior.

But in the end, is that enough reason to give up on influence marketing altogether?

What Brands Really Care About

Whether or not some social users are fed up with the behavior of influencers, brands only want to know one thing: are influencers still a good investment? And the answer to that is a resolute “yes”.

Firstly – according to recent reports – marketers may spend up to $10 billion on influencer marketing in 2020. That’s because influencer marketing yields an average $5.20 for every dollar spent, and it could easily be higher: fraud drives the average ROI of influencer marketing down significantly, and when that issue is addressed, profits will rise.

Secondly, while influencer marketing has been inexorably associated with Instagram, new social platforms are giving a new generation of influencers a chance. In March of this year, we predicted that the new social platform TikTok would be a goldmine for advertising to Gen-Z. Less than five months later, sponsored content shared by rising stars has taken off across the site, showing that influencer marketing is still far from dead.

Finally, while it’s true that more users find influencers annoying it’s also true that they find advertising even more annoying, and largely prefer the influencer approach. In spite of bad publicity, younger audience segments are likely to trust digital influencers as people, making them the ideal channel for reaching Gen-Z.

Getting Through the Growing Pains

While there are more than enough reasons to keep investing in influencers, brands can’t be blamed for feeling wary. These are the early years of an idea that has plenty of maturing to do, and every new marketing strategy goes through “growing pains” in its infancy. Search engines brought keyword stuffing, email brought spam, and banner ads brought malware redirects.

Likewise, influencer marketing has suffered from an onslaught of abuses that is partially responsible for the negative media coverage it has received lately. By simply knowing what these abuses are and how to mitigate them, brands can spend on influencers with relative confidence as the industry slowly reaches stability.

Here are the “growing pains” you should be aware of when investing in influencers, and a few tips to keep them from hurting your image or bottom line:

  1. Fake Followers

Because influencers typically charge by the number of followers on their social accounts, there is plenty of incentive to artificially boost the number with bots and other fake accounts. While it looks impressive, the result is significantly reduced engagement for businesses and a lot of wasted ad-spend.

According to a report from cybersecurity company Cheq, fake followers will likely cost companies $1.3 billion by the end of this year. That’s about 12.5% of the $8 billion that they will spend in total – a significant loss.

Fortunately, there are simple ways to make sure your influencers are legitimate:

  • Ask for the results of previous campaigns conducted by the influencer to ensure a reasonable profit margin
  • Visually inspect social media accounts for engagement, comparing the ratio of followers to comments/likes with legitimate accounts
  • Avoid newly created accounts, or accounts with a suspiciously high number of followers.
  1. FTC Violations

The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) requires influencers to provide “acceptable disclosure” when featuring sponsored content. In other words, users should be minimally aware when an influencer is being paid to advertise a product.

Influencers sometimes try to dodge this requirement, either by leaving out disclosures completely, or by hiding them in the hashtags of a post. However, these practices can result in formal warnings and negative publicity when the FTC notices.

Make sure to read and understand the FTC’s acceptable disclosure requirements before contracting an influencer. Check previous posts to see if they meet the standards and remind your partners of these requirements before starting a campaign.

  1. Manipulative Behavior

If future influencers have a stereotype to fight against, it’s manipulative behavior. As mentioned earlier in this article, influencers have not only staged drama to earn publicity and sympathy from followers, but less professional influencers can also be very pushy in their business practices.

Hotels, resorts, businesses and other picturesque or high-value places have expressed frustration at the onslaught of influencers who feel entitled to free services and paid travel expenses in exchange for exposure. Not only does this generate negative publicity, but the influencer’s business can suffer as a result, and the working relationship may not be a pleasant one.

To avoid this problem,

  • Vet an influencer’s history closely – keep an eye open for aggression, “drama” and others marks of unprofessional/manipulative behavior
  • Give micro-influencers some love – micro-influencers are either just starting out or maintain a carefully curated social presence. They are less likely to cause a scene than “macro-influencers,” and have a more devoted audience
  1. Unreasonable Prices

Some influencers have an inflated sense of their own worth and ask way too much money for a sponsored post or shout-out. Fortunately, the industry standards for influencer marketing are fairly standardized:

  • The average cost for a Facebook post is $25.00/1000 followers
  • For Instagram, $10/1000 followers (or $1 per 100)
  • Also for Instagram, $250 - $750/1000 engagements
  • For Twitter, $2/1000 followers
  • For YouTube, $20/1000 subscribers

While the price that influencers charge will vary a little bit from the average – which may have to do with the quality of their own original content, the loyalty of their followers, and many other factors – avoid those who charge wildly more.

The Future is Influencers

As Atlantic columnist Taylor Lorenz highlighted, the distinction between “influencer” and “entertainer” is disappearing – so too is the distinction between “influencer” and everybody else. As media becomes further democratized, everyone on the Internet has some influence over some part of it.

Influencer marketing is not liable to disappear any time soon, because in the future – when the Internet is more heavily regulated and media fatigue makes ads less effective – one thing will remain: the influence people have over each other.

Conveyance Marketing Group is a team of bright, innovative and talented veteran marketers dedicated to big ideas, fresh insights and measurable results. We pride ourselves on taking challenging marketing issues and turning them into opportunities for our clients, on pointing brands in the right direction, and on getting our customers noticed both online and off. From branding to websites to digital marketing, and public relations, we handle all your marketing communication needs! Web Design and Development | Brand Strategy | Inbound Marketing | Social Media | SEO | PR

Kristine Jacobson

Kristine Jacobson

Kristine Jacobson has more than 25 years of marketing and communications experience with notable corporate leaders as well as emerging market contenders. She offers expert marketing strategy with a touch of creative flair. Her extensive knowledge of strategic marketing, marketing plan execution, and branding illuminate the big picture without losing sight of the details.